Home / Refurbished vs new phones

Refurbished vs new phones

Some links on this page are ads. We may earn a commission if you buy, at no extra cost to you. How we make money

Short answerFor most people a refurbished phone from a business is worth it: you get a tested phone, at least a 12-month warranty and the same legal rights as buying new (CCPC, Back Market). The trade-off is some cosmetic wear and a battery that is not brand new.

What "refurbished" means

A refurbished phone has been used before, then checked, cleaned, reset and resold by a business. On Back Market, sellers run up to a 100-point inspection on smartphones, and phones must not be locked, stolen or fraudulently sourced (Back Market quality promise).

Refurbished vs new vs second-hand from a person

Refurbished (business)NewPrivate seller
Consumer rightsYes, same as newYesNo
Warranty12 months minimum on Back Market and refurbedMaker's warrantyUsually none
Returns14-day legal cooling-off online, 30 days on Back Market and refurbed14 days onlineUsually none
LooksGraded: from visible marks to like newPerfectUnknown
BatteryMinimum 80% to 90% depending on shop and grade100%Unknown

Sources: CCPC buying goods, CCPC buying online, Back Market returns, refurbed, refurbed grades.

Who should buy refurbished

  • You want a recent iPhone, Samsung or Pixel and do not need it sealed in a box.
  • You are happy with light marks in return for a lower price.
  • You want a phone for a child or as a backup.

Who might prefer new

  • You want the newest model on launch day.
  • You need a perfect battery for heavy all-day use and do not want to check battery health.

How to buy well

  1. Pick the model first with our phone finder.
  2. Choose a grade: see grades explained.
  3. Check the battery percentage and warranty length on the listing.
  4. Keep your order confirmation; it is your proof of purchase.

Buying refurbished is a good time to look at your plan too. If your phone is unlocked, compare a SIM-only plan with what you pay now.

Lyca Mobile SIM-only: pay-as-you-go bundles, no contract.

See plans at Lyca

Questions

Is refurbished the same as second-hand?

Not quite. Both have been used before, but a refurbished phone is checked, reset and sold by a business with a warranty. A phone from a private seller comes with no consumer rights.

Do refurbished phones get software updates?

Yes, updates come from Apple, Samsung or Google, not the seller. Newer models get updates for longer, which is why our finder favours them when the budget allows.

Find the right phone in 5 taps

Budget, brand, what matters most. We suggest 2 to 3 phones with a button to the shop.

Start the phone finder

Sources

Checked 25 October 2026. Some links are affiliate links: if you buy, the shop may pay MobileIreland a small commission at no extra cost to you. It never changes which phones we suggest. How we make money.